Duke vs. North Carolina. Blue Devils vs. Tarheels. Upity rich kid private school vs. blue-collar state school. Sweaty, hot, congested gym vs. 20,000 seat capacity arena. There is no question that this rivalry ranks right up there with the very best in sports. Examples like the Red Sox vs. Yankees, Auburn - Alabama football, and Cubs vs. Cardinals come to mind. While almost every collegiate program has some historical rivalry nothing quite matches Carolina-Duke when it comes to intensity, the relative success of both programs, the proximity of where the schools are located, and the dichotomy of the student bodies. Tonight's clash is just another in the long and storied history of this rivalry. Unlike many of the other traditional rivalries in sports, however, these games don't really matter to the future of each respective team. Let me explain.
The NCAA tournament in my opinion is the single greatest championship event in sports. However, because the tournament is so outstanding, it really takes away from the importance of the regular season in college basketball. What if North Carolina, who is widely regarded as the favorite to win this year's National Championship, loses tonight? Will they honestly be anything worse than #2 seed when the tournament field is announced? Not only is the answer no, but if they lose tonight the odds are that they will win the majority of their remaining games and still end up as a #1 seed. The same can be said for Duke. If Carolina beats them tonight on their home floor, are they looking at any worse post-season positioning than if they win? Because their conference is one of the top 2 in the nation, because both schools are traditional powers with proven success in the post season and multiple National Championships between them, they are going to be high seeds when it comes to be touranment time. The success of the NCAA tournament has largely made the regular season in college basketball irrelevant. A team still has to have a good year, but when you have conferences like the Big East whose eighth place team will probably still get into the tournament with a decent seed, it really diminishes the role the regular season plays.
The current system that college football employs is by far the worst of any sport that we have today. That fact is not debatable. Even sports like NASCAR and golf have implemented psuedo playoof systems in the hopes of generating more buzz about their respective sports. Bash the BCS all you want, and probably rightly so, but because of the system that is in place every regular season game is crucial for a team's national championship aspirations. Now the debate comes in when you have multiple teams that believe they have a claim to the National Championship Game when the season is over. That is why the system is unfair and needs to be changed. But every given Saturday in the fall, there are upsets and big time games that really do impact the landscape of college football for the rest of the year. That is why television ratings for college football are always so high. Look at the ratings for college basketball. The NCAA tournament does great, especially the opening Thursday and Friday, but the regular season goes largely unwatched by the majority of the nation. Can you imagine if college football went to a 64 team playoff? All the drama of the regular season would be gone. That is exactly what has happened to college basketball.
So as it applies to Duke and Carolina, yes, the rivalry is great. There have been historic battles, fantastic games, and thrilling finishes. And yes, they are unquestionably the biggest rivals in the game. But realistically, what are the implications of tonights contest? Other than bragging rights for fans, players, and maybe battles for some recruits, nothing will be solved as far as each team's respective destiny for the rest of the year. Don't get me wrong, the rivalry is certainly as passionate and intense as it comes. If one team loses and then ends up as a #2 seed and plays Belmont in the first round of the tournament, and the other gets to play the some anonymous #16 seed, what's the difference? Until they are fighting to see who moves on and who goes home, I'm just not that interested.
Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment