Monday, February 9, 2009

We've seen this before and we will see it again. Another story of an extremely successful and prominent professional athlete falling victim to the pressures of money, fame, fortune, and legacy. Alex Rodriguez has admitted to using performance enhancing drugs, and by doing so has dealt a significant blow to the entire establishment of Major League Baseball and to legions of fans everywhere. While there is almost no aspect of this story that has not yet been talked about and discussed at length by sports journalists, radio hosts, and television personalities everywhere, I can't help but share a few of my own revelelations on the subject.

There has been a lot of talk about who is to blame, where A-Rod goes from here, how his legacy will forever be changed, the culpability of the player's union and their role throughout this process, the response he should give to the American public, his Hall of Fame status in the future, and on and on and on. Frankly, these are all topics that can be discussed at length and should be further expanded upon. There are a million different stances and angles to take in this saga because of who the player is (as polarizing as we have in the game), how much money he makes (10 years, $225.2 million if you forgot), and where he plays (biggest fishbowl ever). Many people want to compare A-Rod to the others in his particular sport that have tarnished legacies or have links to performance enhancing drugs; names like Bonds, MacGuire, Palmeiro, Clemmens, and Canseco. While these are natural comparisons, I tend to liken the situation to that of another superstar, in another sport.

It wasn't too long ago that another in his prime fell prey to the temptation that comes with the lifestyle of being a superstar athlete. Kobe Bryant spent almost the entire 2003-2004 NBA season flying back and forth to Eagle County, Colorado to make court appearences in his sexual assault case. If my recollection serves me correctly, charges were filed against Kobe by a 19 year-old female hotel worker. The report surfaced, Bryant was arrested, and a press conference ensued where Bryant was forced to admit that although in his mind he was guilty of no crime, he was in fact "guilty of adultery."

The similarities between the two cases is striking. Both athletes at the top of their respective sports, both with boatloads of endorsement deals and incentive money. They both got caught red-handed in situations they should not have been in. Both were forced to then address the issue and "apologize" for it. My question was the same with Kobe as it is with A-Rod. Are you sorry that you cheated, or are you sorry that you got caught cheating? How much longer would you have continued to cheat if you hadn't been caught? And do you honestly expect us to believe that the one time you cheated you happened to get caught? Different debates for different days perhaps.

While Kobe has largely repaired his image thanks to community work, becoming a more mature team leader, and the ever so played out "bring your kids to the press conference bit" (a gold medal doesn't hurt either), I don't think that A-Rod will be as lucky. First of all, Kobe is not nearly the polarizing figure that A-Rod is. Secondly, while Kobe broke a covenant of marriage, he did not break any of the rules of basketball. As baseball fans know, there are no bigger history buffs or purists anywhere in sports than the baseball writers. They do not forget or forgive quickly or easily. In many cases (a la Pete Rose), they never forget or forgive. There are a lot of bad guys in the Hall of Fame and unfortunately the nicest guys do not always finish first. But while moral offenses are more easily forgiven, in baseball there is absolutely no greater sin than tarnishing the game, and for that A-Rod might not ever be forgiven.

No comments:

Post a Comment